Gadgetry: SC
Stealth: SC x 4
Storyline: Tie but again I like realism so Im leaning towards SC. Then again MGS's certainly was more memmorable . So yeah tie
Motion Sequences: MGS definatly
Graphics: Very close yes but the amazing lighting effects in SC push it over the top. Definatly SC
Sound: Tie becasue there really wasnt much of a difference in quality
Publicity: Who cares
Respect: MGS for sure (Been out longer)
Sorry to copy but its a cool format and Im sick of all this SC bashing
.
__________________
The kinder, gentler, Vicious 
Beretta55- "fo sheezy heezy neezy weezy flipity floppity floop"
Lost Myth- "I already know you are something special and I think the Pistons did too,
because then why would they have won the trophy on your birthday dude?
Anonymous- "Whos more to blame, me for being quote un quote gullible ?, or him for lying !?"