Thread: Help!
View Single Post
Old Sep 25th, 2004, 06:49 PM   #1
happy_doughnut
just a rolling stone
 
happy_doughnut's Avatar
 
Joined: Apr 2002
Location: of what?
Posts: 1,561
happy_doughnut is on a distinguished road
Angry Help!

Hey guys.

Eeks! I should've thought about this sooner.

Anyway, as an English assignment, I have to do a student presentation on "fallacies."

The fallacy I'm supposed to present is that of "two wrongs don't make a right." In a gist, in an argument, this way of thinking is fallacious because the on being accused of a wrong action is trying to justify their actions based on another wrong action.

Kinda like saying: "Well, I did -X because Y did -Z to me."

An example would be: "Capital punishment is fine, since those the state kills don't have any qualms about killing others."

Here, person A is justifying capital punishment on the grounds that killing someone who has killed is fine because they killed in the first place.

My "argument" *cough* is that the thinking of wrong + wrong = right is, in fact, not correct, but rather is fallacious.

Now, I think I can explain this, but the problem is that I need to have concrete examples, and I really can't think of any.

Soooo, I was wondering if any of you guys can think of anything. It doesn't have to be anything serious - it can be something coming from a Disney movie.

I've been looking for a while, but I can't find something that points to this exactly.

If any of you guys have heard of things like this, be it in movies, shows, songs, politics, ect., I would greatly appreciate it if you'd let me know!

Thanks a bunch in advance.
happy_doughnut is offline   Reply With Quote