I have never played Fatal Fram so I really have no comment about it.
Resident Evil games have always been more "nerve-breaking" but not exactly scary or creepy, now, Silent Hill does not have such a big "scare you" factor, but it just puts such fear into my mind that makes me not want to play it, yet, at the same time, makes me want to keep playing so badly, to know what will happen next.
Still need to play SH2 to see if it's actually worse than the first game.
__________________
|