Alright. Give this a whirl.
I'll list a bunch of different categories and reply with what you think deserves the award for it.
I'll add just a few off the top of my head but feel more than free to create more as you think of them.
Best Anime Soundtrack
ex. Cowboy Bebop (my opinion as well)
Best Anime Hero
Best Anime Villain
Best Anime Death Sequence
Best Anime Action Sequence
Fill in the blanks and create some more of these. Hopefully this will create some discussion but not a lot of anger over strong opinions.
Well . . . give'r!